Is a good teacher worth the cost of a lower grade? Image Source

“I seriously need to switch out of this class,” Jamie was telling me, “This teacher is just busting my balls. I can’t get a B…” Jamie was usually a straight A student.

I tilted my head and pursed the corner of my lips. We were talking about our A&P teacher’s seemingly impossible standards.

“I’d fail before I switch,” I said laughing. I was barely scraping B’s in the class.

And… I was completely serious when I said that.

This realization was huge for college.

I scored lower than I was used to in that class. But… I was learning stuff like crazy. The teacher was an absolute beast when it came to violently shoveling A&P knowledge into my skull until I just couldn’t take it anymore. It was a tough class and an amazing teacher.

It would be worth failing that class just to learn as much as I did. You get teachers like that once every dozen classes. Take advantage of it.

But it’s not that simple, there are a few complications:

The High School Dilemma

There is a dilemma for high school students looking to learn as much as possible because this instinct can end up hurting their college opportunities. Image Source

Some high school students are forced to maintain a precarious balance in school.

They want to learn from their teachers but, at the same time, they’re trying to keep their grades high enough to get into a competitive college. Would they rather score an A and learn less or score a B and learn more?

An ‘A’ may get you into a better college.

But… learning more means you’d do better once you get to college and your future in general. Learning less just feels like a waste of talent. If you can learn more, shouldn’t you want to learn more?

The solution to this dilemma isn’t hard to find when you understand the value of college:

95% of colleges aren’t worth competing to get into. Sure… they’re good investments. They’re just not hard to appreciate the benefits of. They’re a dime a dozen but cost you 400,000 times that. 5% of colleges are top-notch investments in your future.

Are you competing for that top 5% of colleges?

Take Your Success has a great take on this. Sometimes your GPA matters. Most of the time, it doesn’t.

If so, you’re not in the business of learning more. You’re in the business of competing for limited spots. The vast majority of students that get accepted to these colleges will be using every advantage they can get. Choosing the noble act of learning more is a symbolic gesture that will not pay off in the short run. It will just decrease your chances of getting accepted.

If you’re not competing for the top 5% of colleges then you’re in the comfortable majority.

You’re going to school. (I’m assuming you’ve decided that already.) You don’t need to waste your time in easy classes. It’s pointless. Sure… you can do it but it won’t help you. You’re stuck going to class anyway. You might as well learn as much as possible. (Sometimes that will be in a class where you struggle to score high. Sometimes it will be in an easy to score high class.)

It may not feel good to go home with a mediocre looking grade but that’s not all you’ll go home with. You’ll also have the experience and knowledge to deal with your future classes better. In the long run, you win.

What About The College Dilemma?

College students face a similar dilemma. Image Source

The high school dilemma revolves around the choice between a better college or learning more.

The college dilemma revolves around the choice between a better gpa on your resume or learning more.

Should you focus on scoring higher to get a better job or learning more?

Scoring higher may give you better job opportunities. Learning more could do the same. The difference is ultimately the time frame.

When you’re applying for your first job, your GPA may be a factor. This is particularly true if you’re competing for exclusive internships. But if you can’t back it up with knowledge then, like it or not, this is going to be a short term head start. You might make more but eventually the lower scoring students that learned more will catch up.

For the most part, I don’t believe there is a college dilemma. Whatever you pick, you’re not losing out. Manage your college schedule in a way that makes you happy. Both ways can work.

One Quick Exception: If you’re not planning to work in the field more than 5 or 10 years then consider focusing on your GPA. That means you’ll start with a higher paycheck. By the time the more prepared students catch up, you’ll be leaving the business and enjoying a higher return.

A Worse Grade Doesn’t Mean A Better Teacher

Don’t forget the importance of apples for bribery and hunger. Image Source

This is the most important caveat to my point in this article.

This isn’t about finding classes where your grades suck or your teachers are miserable buffoons. It’s about how to deal with those oddball courses where you know your grade will suffer but you also know you will learn a lot.

Sometimes good teachers hold students to high standards. Sometimes bad teachers hold students up to ridiculous standards. Try and distinguish the difference.

Once you start to notice it you’ll be able to manage a ton more in school.

These are the usual signs to look for:

Do poor students complain about the teacher being tough?

Do high-scoring students complain about the teacher being tough?

Do average students seem to enjoy the class?

Is A Good Teacher Worth A Worse Score?

If you get a yes to all three questions then you may not have an easy to ace course but you probably have a wonderful learning opportunity. If you’re in the right situation then take advantage of it.

You will only have so many great teachers in your life. A great teacher is the most valuable resource you’ll ever have in any subject. A great teacher can permanently improve your future in any and every field. They can get you motivated. They can make you appreciate subjects you’ve never appreciated in the past. They can change your life for the better.

Naturally, you need to manage your grades in some situations but don’t miss a great opportunity to learn when you get it.

Is A Good Teacher Worth A Worse Score?

The Secret To Success

I’ve worked with students for over a decade now –

There is a thing that all successful students (and I suspect all successful people at anything) have in common…

It’s this thing that can come off as crazy – wrong-headed – almost embarrassing.

But those of us that see it and understand it know –

It’s not embarrassing. It’s not wrong-headed. And it’s not crazy. It’s actually one of the most powerful forces in the world.

When I see someone that understands and applies this, I know they’re a person I can trust to get something done. It’s like a secret handshake. It’s like our personal secret conspiracy we’re using to take over the world. And most people just dismiss it.

In fact, I can tell you right now and 95% of you are going to dismiss it.

And only 5% of you will do it.

The secret: Do it. If it works, keep doing it. If it doesn’t, do something else.

If you’re ready to do it – to succeed extraordinarily in academics and life then let me send you the details by putting in your email below and checking the box.

Or you can let that doubt take over. That’s your business.

You are requesting contact through:


I agree to be added to this mailing list where I will receive study tips, your free gifts, and promotional offers from Aaron & Smart Student Secrets.


We use Mailchimp as our marketing platform. By clicking below to subscribe, you acknowledge that your information will be transferred to Mailchimp for processing. Learn more about Mailchimp’s privacy practices here.


We hate spam! We protect your email with one of the biggest and most secure email platforms in the world. Your email will not be shared.

Tagged on:                         

5 thoughts on “Is A Good Teacher Worth A Worse Score?

  • October 30, 2019 at 5:08 pm

    I discovered your article by accident nevertheless i’m glad i’m here. Good stuff i’m reading.

  • October 28, 2019 at 1:47 am

    Hi there, nice information. Now i’m empowered by your blog posts here. Ideally in the near future i’m going to be publishing quality blogs similar to this. Love this.!!

  • September 29, 2019 at 5:11 am

    Really nice info that you revealed in this article.

  • April 10, 2017 at 3:14 pm

    I’ve always been a fan of the easy A’s.

    It’s strange of the difficulty of most courses isn’t determined by the subject. It’s determined by the teacher. I think I read that on this site before. Colleges track the difficulty of the courseload but they don’t track the difficulty of the teachers. That means an easy A teacher can still look like a super hard class to the college.

    • April 10, 2017 at 6:17 pm

      That’s the truth your preaching!

      And I’ve definitely mentioned similar things in the past.

      I can’t say easy A’s are always the right approach but when it comes to competing for grades, I agree completely.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *